What’s the Right Time to Invest in a Website Redesign—and What Should I Do First?

Summary:

If your website looks fine but isn’t performing—or if your business has outgrown it—it may be time to redesign. But don't start with visuals. Start by asking: what’s not working, who is it for, and what’s the goal? A successful website redesign begins with strategy, not software. Prioritize user journeys, performance gaps, and alignment with your brand goals before touching the design.

Is It Time for a Website Redesign?

Redesigning your website is a big investment—not just in cost, but in time and attention. So how do you know it’s time?

Look for these red flags:

1. Your Site Isn’t Converting

High traffic, low conversions? That’s a performance issue, not just a design problem. Your messaging, layout, or UX may be misaligned with user intent.

2. Your Business Has Outgrown the Site

If your offerings, audience, or brand positioning have evolved but your website hasn’t, you’re leaving opportunities (and credibility) on the table.

3. It’s Not Mobile-Optimized

In 2025, a non-responsive site isn’t just outdated—it’s invisible to a large segment of users and punished by search engines.

4. The Backend Is a Nightmare

If updating a headline requires a dev ticket, it’s time for a CMS upgrade. Tech debt kills momentum.

5. The Design Feels “Off”

Design isn’t just aesthetics—it’s trust. An outdated look can make even great companies feel irrelevant.

Before You Touch the Design, Start Here

Many businesses jump into a website redesign by hiring a designer and brainstorming layouts. That’s like building a house without a blueprint.

Instead, begin with strategy and structure:

1. Define Your Primary Goal

What’s the #1 thing your website should accomplish?

  • Lead generation?

  • Product sales?

  • Booking demos?

  • Educating and nurturing?

Your content, layout, and flow should revolve around this goal.

2. Map the User Journey

Think from your customer’s POV:

  • What questions are they asking?

  • What objections need to be addressed?

  • How do they arrive, and what should they see first?

Start with key user paths, not pages.

3. Audit What’s Working (and What’s Not)

Use tools like:

  • Google Analytics (user behavior & drop-off points)

  • Hotjar or Microsoft Clarity (clicks and scrolls)

  • CRM and sales feedback

Don’t toss everything—identify which parts of your current site convert, and build from there.

4. Align Brand and Messaging

If your brand voice, positioning, or visuals have changed since your last build, your website should reflect that. Ask:

  • Does your tone match who you’re talking to now?

  • Are you telling a clear, compelling story?

  • Is your call to action consistent and prominent?

5. Plan for Growth and Flexibility

Your new site should scale with you. Choose platforms and frameworks that let you:

  • Add new pages easily

  • Create content without dev help

  • Adjust messaging for campaigns

A sleek website is useless if it’s locked down and inflexible.

The Website Redesign Process (at a High Level)

Once your strategy is clear, move through these stages:

  1. Discovery & Research – Analytics, audience interviews, brand review

  2. Information Architecture – Sitemap, user flows, content needs

  3. Wireframing & UX Design – Layout before visuals

  4. Visual Design – Branding, colors, typography, UI elements

  5. Development – Responsive, fast-loading, accessible build

  6. Testing & Launch – QA, device checks, SEO prep

  7. Ongoing Optimization – Heatmaps, A/B testing, speed tuning

Redesigning a Website Isn’t Just a Design Problem—it’s a Strategy Decision

If your site isn’t performing, changing fonts and colors won’t fix it. Start by asking the hard questions: what’s broken, who are we speaking to, and what are we trying to achieve?

Redesign from strategy—not frustration.

Need Help Planning Your Website Redesign?

Whether you’re starting from scratch or looking to optimize what you’ve got, I help businesses design websites that perform as good as they look. Let’s build something that works for your users and your bottom line.

Explore more posts

Article

Headless, Hybrid, or Traditional CMS: Choosing the Right Stack for Real Humans

Choosing between a traditional, headless, or hybrid CMS can feel like a purely technical decision. It isn’t. This post breaks down each model through the lens of editors, developers, and end users so you can pick a stack that supports real content workflows, multi-channel experiences, and long-term flexibility without overengineering...
Marketing for different personality types
Article

Designing for Different Brains: Using DISC to Shape Better Marketing and Customer Experiences

This post reframes audience research through the DISC model—Red, Yellow, Green, and Blue—so you can spot behavioral patterns in your data and design experiences that match how different personalities make decisions....
Journal Entry

The 1–3–5 Rule: My Favorite Way to Keep My ADHD (Mostly) in Check

My ADHD loves big plans and then forgetting all of them. The 1–3–5 rule is how I keep that from running my life: one workout, three acts of basic care, five small learning blocks every day. Paired with a Sunday planner ritual, it turns to-do lists into actual promises I...
Article

The New Attention Funnel: Designing Campaigns for People Who Don’t Want to Look Up

Most buyers aren’t giving your campaign their full attention. They’re skimming between notifications and tabs. This post reframes the classic funnel as attention windows and shows how to design campaigns that earn one more second, then another, until you finally win real focus with creative, UX, and media working together....
Article

Designing a Brand for Both Buyers and Employees

Most brand work is either outward-facing (“What do customers think of us?”) or inward-facing (“How do we attract talent?”). The problem is that your buyers and your employees experience the same company. When the story they’re told doesn’t match the reality inside, trust erodes fast. A modern brand has to...

Article

Accessibility as a Competitive Advantage, Not a Checklist

Accessibility is often treated as a late-stage checklist item, but it is one of the fastest ways to improve overall UX, expand your market, and build trust. This post reframes accessibility as a strategic advantage and walks through concrete, realistic ways to bake it into design, development, and content from...