How Do I Know If My Brand Positioning Is Actually Working—or Just Sounds Good in a Pitch Deck?

Summary:

Brand positioning isn’t about what sounds good in a pitch deck—it’s about what sticks in the minds of real customers. If your positioning is working, you’ll see it reflected in customer behavior, brand recall, sales performance, and even how your team talks about the company. If you're not seeing consistency, clarity, or traction across those signals, it's time to revisit your strategy.

What Is Brand Positioning, Really?

At its core, brand positioning defines the space your brand occupies in the minds of your audience. It’s the why you—why someone should choose your product or service over another.

It should be:

  • Clear – No jargon, no fluff

  • Distinctive – Not a copy-paste of your competitors

  • Relevant – Speaks directly to what your audience actually cares about

  • Memorable – Easy to recall and emotionally resonant

If your positioning doesn’t check those boxes, it might impress internally but fall flat externally.

How to Tell If Your Brand Positioning Is Actually Working

1. Do Customers Repeat It Back to You?

One of the strongest indicators of brand resonance is when your customers or users echo your messaging. Are you hearing your tagline, core benefit, or mission repeated in:

  • Customer interviews?

  • Reviews and testimonials?

  • Social media mentions?

If the market isn’t repeating your message, they’re not remembering it.

2. Is There Consistency Across Channels and Teams?

Strong positioning creates internal alignment. If different departments (sales, marketing, support) explain what you do in totally different ways, your positioning hasn’t landed—or hasn’t been shared clearly.

Look for:

  • Messaging consistency in emails, social, decks

  • Confidence in elevator pitches across your org

  • Visual and verbal brand harmony

3. Are You Attracting the Right People (and Repelling the Wrong Ones)?

Good brand positioning doesn’t just bring leads—it brings the right ones. It should:

  • Qualify ideal customers

  • Deter poor-fit prospects

  • Set expectations up front

If you’re constantly dealing with misaligned leads or poor customer fit, your positioning may be too broad or too vague.

4. Do Metrics Match Your Message?

Brand positioning isn’t just about words—it’s about impact. Cross-reference your brand promise with your data:

  • Do users behave in a way that aligns with what you say you offer?

  • Are customers engaging with your most important brand-led content?

  • Is retention improving alongside brand efforts?

Look for traction in brand search volume, conversion from brand campaigns, or NPS comments that reflect your core value prop.

5. Would People Miss You If You Disappeared?

This sounds philosophical, but it’s a gut-check for brand stickiness. If your brand vanished tomorrow:

  • Would anyone care?

  • Would they be able to describe what’s missing?

  • Would they know how to replace you?

If the answer is “meh,” you’ve got a positioning problem.

How to Fix Weak Brand Positioning

If you’re not seeing the results above, try:

  • Customer interviews – Ask real users how they describe your brand

  • Message testing – Run A/B tests on headlines, taglines, or value props

  • Competitive analysis – Make sure your language and position are differentiated

  • Internal training – Get your team aligned with a simple brand narrative

Positioning Isn’t a One-Time Project

It evolves. As your audience changes, your product matures, and your market shifts, your positioning should adapt. What worked at launch may not work at scale.

Don’t confuse clarity with rigidity. The best brands know when to double down—and when to pivot.

Need a Second Set of Eyes on Your Brand Strategy?

If your positioning sounds good on paper but isn’t showing up in customer behavior, I can help. Let’s dig into the gaps and rebuild a brand story that actually connects—and converts.

Explore more posts

Article

Beyond Carrots and Sticks: Why Reward-and-Punishment Leadership Fails (And What to Do Instead)

Dangle a carrot, swing a stick—neither creates lasting motivation. This post dives into why these tactics fall short and what modern leaders can do instead to drive real engagement....
FAQ

What Is Hyper-Personalization in Marketing—And How Do You Actually Use It?

Most marketers stop at basic personalization—but your audience expects more. Here’s how hyper-personalization works, what makes it powerful, and how to use it without losing the human touch....
Article

Why Most Advertising Doesn’t Work—And What to Do Instead

The problem with most advertising isn’t creativity or budget—it’s behavioral friction. If your ads aren’t performing, there’s a good chance they’re interrupting instead of integrating. Here’s why that happens and how to rethink your strategy....
Close-up of a team collaborating on a customer journey map using sticky notes and printed diagrams
FAQ

How Do I Create a Customer Journey Map That Actually Helps My Business?

A customer journey map shouldn’t be a pretty poster that sits on a wall. It should be a practical tool that helps you see your business from your customer’s perspective—and make smarter decisions because of it....
Article

The Hidden Cost of Off-Brand Design: A Behavioral Perspective

You don’t need a broken logo to break your brand. Off-brand design chips away at trust in ways most teams never notice—until conversion rates, engagement, or credibility quietly stall. Here’s what’s really happening beneath the surface....
Woman with long wavy blonde hair enjoying a peaceful morning with a coffee cup on a sunlit porch.
Journal Entry

What I Know Now About Rest That I Didn’t at 25

At 25, I thought rest was something you earned. Now I know better. Rest isn’t a reward—it’s a necessity. A form of strength. A skill worth practicing. In this journal entry, I reflect on how my understanding of rest has evolved—and what it truly means to protect your energy without...